August 03 , 2015

(50%)

'Survivor: Amazon'

'Survivor: All Stars'

Revolutionized the game of Survivor in the Amazon, but was unfortunately not awarded with a victory. The "greatest Survivor contestant never to have won" rightfully takes his spot amongst the 'Survivor: Legends' dream cast.

(45.45%)

'Survivor: Borneo'

'Survivor: All Stars'

Legal issues have perhaps robbed viewers of being able to see the "Grandaddy of them all" Richard Hatch return to Survivor since his underwhelming outing in 'All Stars', but it would be fascinating to see how Richard would fair in the modern game. You can't have a 'Survivor: Legends' cast without the first ever winner.

(38.64%)

'Survivor: Panama"

It goes without saying that the majority of us are still devestated at not getting to see Shane return for 'Survivor: Cambodia'. Love him or hate him, fans have still not given up seeing Shane return and he has taken his place here on the Survivor: Legends list.

(38.64%)

'Survivor: Cagayan'

Our most recent castaway on this 'Legends' list, Tony put on a highly entertaining show in Cagayan that kept the audience and his castmates guessing. A highly regarded winner from a highly regarded season. And in the eyes of many, already a 'Survivor: Legend'.

(31.82%)

'Survivor: Africa',

'Survivor: All Stars'.

One of my personal favourites, in my opinion the only issue with Lex was that he was before his time. A true strategist and underrated physical player I think Lex would adapt perfectly to modern-day Survivor. A true legend of the show. Would love to see him and his famous "gut" make a return.

(29.55%)

'Survivor: Palau'

Ian may have moved on from Survivor but his fans sure haven't forgotten about him. Ian was guilted into letting Tom win the final immunity challenge and the audience were robbed of a chance for what would have been the greatest final 2 show down ever. 

A physical, social and strategic threat Ian is the one contestant that I would love to see return more than any other.

And I'm stoked to see him voted as a 'Survivor: Legend' by other fans.

(27.27%)

'Survivor: Australian Outback'

'Survivor: All Stars'

'Survivor: Heroes Vs Villains'.

I was probably more surprised than I should've been to see Colby make this list. Our first (and only) male three time player to make this list, it seems that despite his disinterest in HvV, there is no denying Colby's legendary status in the game of Survivor. If you were to ask any casual fan of the game to name a castaway from the early days of Survivor, 9/10 I imagine would say Colby. 

(27.27%)

'Survivor: Pearl Islands'

'Survivor: Micronesia'

Every season needs a villain, and why not go straight to the top for the ultimate Survivor "villain" the always entertaining and polarizing Jonny Fairplay. 

Left disappointingly early in Micronesia, but perhaps a different headspace would see Fairplay fair well in a Legends season.

(27.27%)

'Survivor: China'

Despite publicised personal issues Todd remains a 'Survivor Legend' in many fans eyes. Our third and final male winner to make this list absolutely nailed it in China and I personally would love to see him again on our Survivor screens.

(27.27%)

'Survivor: Marquesas'

I'm going to admit I am not the biggest 'Marquesas' fan, but I am thrilled that the two people from that season to make this list are so highly deserving. Off to a huge start as leader of the Rotu Four, John was ousted after those outside the alliance decided to shake things up in epic fashion. Years later it would be great to see how an older, wiser John would fair amongst other "Survivor: Legends'